|
PREVENTIVE CONSERVATION
A
museum's primary purpose is to ensure that its collections
are available for future generations. A popular image is of
white-coated conservators working in laboratories to
stabilise and repair items that have suffered from damage or
neglect. This is remedial conservation. It is,
however, more efficient to prevent or reduce decay from
occurring in the first place. This is preventive
conservation.
Preventive
conservation is a process that seeks to prevent, reduce or
mitigate the effect of all the factors that, every day,
threaten an object's continued survival. It requires an
all-embracing approach - a constant assessment of how
collections are stored, handled, displayed and maintained.
It should involve all people who work for a museum, not
simply conservators. Good building repair and maintenance
routines are as necessary for long-term survival as the more
obvious and immediate issues of object handling, storage and
security. Preventive conservation is a strategic enterprise
driven by a museum's primary purpose, that cannot be
introduced without planning, or its benefits demonstrated in
other than the long term.
Deterioration
is a continuous, natural process. It can, however, be
slowed; indeed, science has suggested ways in which the
natural lifespan of most museum objects can be extended.
Many of these techniques are based on common-sense and good
housekeeping. However, these must inevitably be reinforced
by the results of current research, and access to specialist
information is vital if an informed approach is to be taken.
There is benefit in having formal systems in place,
incorporating agreed standards (such as those set by the
Museum & Galleries Commission's Standards in the
Museum Care of ... Collections). Appropriate and
continuing training, to ensure consistency in approach over
time and between individuals, is also vital.
Table
1 summarises the major threats to museum collections, how
they are caused, and the action that can be taken to remove
or reduce their impact.
WHERE TO BEGIN?
An
intensive museum-wide study of the current situation - a preventive
conservation audit -will enable a museum to:
.
assess the degree of danger posed by the threats to
that individual museum
.
establish the priority areas for action
.
demonstrate the benefits, in quantifiable terms, of
any changes it introduces
The
preventive conservation audit should work methodically,
ideally gathering data and making consideration in this
order:
.
the building
.
the collection
.
the in-house
procedures
TABLE 1 - Preventive Conservation - a
summary of the threats (and their possible remedies)
|
THREAT |
SPECIFIC |
DAMAGE |
FREQUENT CAUSE |
PREVENTIVE ACTION |
|
People
|
. Staff
. Visitors
. Intruders
|
. Breakage
. Abrasion
. Crushing
. Theft |
. Unnecessary handling
- open displays
- badly organised stores
- inadequate labelling
. Incorrect handling
. Inappropriate cleaning
. Insufficient supervision
. Inadequate physical or electronic protection
|
. Prevent visitors touching objects
. Re-organise the store
. Label stored objects clearly
. Handle only as required, using approved
procedures
. Upgrade physical and electronic security
. Train & motivate staff
See `In-house Procedures' for more detail |
|
Relative
Humidity
|
. Incorrect humidity level (high or low)
. Rapid fluctuation in RH |
. High humidity causes
- mould growth
- corrosion
. Low humidity causes
embrittlement
. Fluctuation causes
- splitting - cockling - warping1 |
. Weather changes
. Floods & leaks
. Damp visitor clothing
. Wet-cleaning of floors
. Building re-decoration
. Rising damp
. Poor building insulation (temperature and/or
humidity transmission)
. Poor ventilation
. Inappropriate heating source2 or
temperature control regulation |
. Regularly measure & record RH
. Move collections to best environment
. Improve air circulation
. Introduce visitor cloakrooms
. Improve insulation
. Attempt to impose RH control (by
humidifiers/dehumidifiers, air-conditioning or use of
heating/temperature control3)
See Appendix 1 for more detail |
|
Temperature |
. Incorrect temperature (high or low)
. Rapid fluctuation in temperature |
. Heat causes
- increase in degradation4
- embrittle- ment
. Fluctuation causes - splitting
- cockling
- warping1 |
. Weather changes
. Poor building insulation
. Poor regulation of heating
. Radiant heat from display lighting |
. Regularly measure & record temperature
. Improve insulation
. Mount lights externally to display cases
. Control temperature (by air-conditioning or use
of heating/humidity control)
See Appendix 1 for more detail |
|
Light |
. Exposure to excessive light especially
- high intensity light
- short wavelength light
(ultraviolet) |
. Fading
. Discolouration
. Embrittle-
ment1
. Destruction |
. Natural & artificial light
. Too many windows
. Objects wrongly positioned
. Inappropriate artificial light sources
. Lack of filters or blinds |
. easure light intensity & ultraviolet (UV)
levels
. Filter to reduce UV light
. Reduce light intensity in display areas
. Reduce display times
. If appropriate, set annual lux hours exposure
limit
. Block out all light from stores
See Appendix 2 for more detail |
|
Pests
|
. Birds
. Rodents
- Rats, Mice
. Insects
- Moth, Beetles
. Mould
. Fungus |
. Objects eaten
. Objects soiled5 |
. Gaps in building shell
. Damp (high relative humidity)
. Unchecked new acquisitions/loans
. Poor cleaning
. Attractants & food sources used in displays
(eg plants & display props)
|
. Regularly monitor with traps
. Inspect all new acquisitions
. Label & regularly inspect vulnerable items
. Isolate infested items immediately
. Keep store cool
. Maintain building shell
. Avoid damp or humid areas
. Regular & thorough cleaning of stores &
display areas
See Appendix 3 for more detail |
|
Pollutants |
. Wind-borne gas & particle pollutants,
especially
- oxidant & sulphiding gases
- dirt & dust |
. Degradation of materials |
. Close proximity to road
. Lack of air-filtration
. Poor door/window fitting
. Poor housekeeping
. Poor control of building/decorating works
. Inappropriate cleaning methods & agents |
. Identify the type & sources of gaseous
& particulate pollution
. Determine the degree of risk
. Reduce ingress and/or circulation
- create air/dust breaks
- use mechanical air- filtration
- repair the building shell
- never use a duster
. Reduce impact on objects
- box or wrap objects in store
- use housekeeping regimes that remove dust &
dirt
See Appendix 4 for more detail |
|
Storage & Display
Materials
|
. Gaseous, chemical and particulate migration
from materials used in construction of display cases,
mounts & frames, storage racks, boxes &
packaging |
. Corrosion
. Discolouration
. Physical Damage (eg staining) |
. Use of inappropriate materials, with high
acidic & migratory characteristics especially
- boards & papers
- composite woods
- many paints
- many glues
- some plastics
- felt & other woollen material |
. Ideally, use only those materials approved
& tested for a particular situation
. Certainly avoid use of known problem materials
. If possible test unknown materials before use;
otherwise seal, cover or vent to mitigate possible
effects
See Appendix 4 for more detail
|
|
Disasters |
. Flood
. Fire
|
. Flood
- staining
- ink & dye run
- mould growth
- warping
- swelling
- disintegra- tion
. Fire
- incineration - scorching - chemical deposit |
. Flood
- burst pipe
- leaking roof
- fire-fighting water
. Fire
- electrical fault
- arson
- accident
- lightning
|
. Formulate a comprehensive Disaster Plan, to
include checklists for all housekeeping
routines and situations, including
- contractors (special care to be taken during
building works)
- maintenance checks (internal & external)
. Enforce no smoking
. Train, motivate & test staff
See `In-house Procedures' for more detail |
|
1
Especially organic based materials (eg paper, leather,
textiles)
2 Especially bottled gas (LPG) heaters
3 Heating a building above the external
temperature will normally lower the humidity; lowering
the temperature will have the opposite effect
4 Every 10° c
increase, degradation rate doubles
5 Especially paper, textiles, wood &
natural history specimens |
THE BUILDING
The
building is the first line of defence, and the audit will
start here. A survey can establish how well the building
cushions the indoor environment from that outdoors, and
isolates the conditions within. If the building has poor
features, yet is capable of satisfactory modification, its
physical improvement should come before consideration of new
internal control equipment that will be expensive to
install, and energy-inefficient to operate.
The
environment within the building should be surveyed using
24-hour recording devices during a full calendar year. An
external sensor, to provide contrasting readings, is
essential to judge the efficiency of the building fabric.
Such a survey may quickly identify the existence of
differing environmental conditions within the building. As
an immediate response, the collection may be moved, and the
most sensitive items placed in the most stable and easily
controlled zones - for example, in rooms near the centre of
the building that are usually furthest from the effects of
the weather. Any additional control measures that are needed
can then be economically and effectively targeted on
specific zones, rather than applied indiscriminately
throughout the building. It may be that no area within the
building can easily be brought to an adequate standard. In
such cases, consideration should be given to relocating the
museum.
TABLE 2 - Surveying a museum building:
good & bad features
|
FEATURE |
GOOD |
BAD |
|
Site |
. Well-drained
. Sheltered (but not shaded) |
. Low-lying . Poorly drained
. Exposed . Shaded |
|
Building Materials |
. Damp-proof course
. Well-insulated . Draught-proof
. Watertight . Good ventilation |
. Rising damp
. Poor insulation
. Draughty |
|
Building Design (external) |
. Pitched roof . Controllable ventilation
. Few windows . Small glazed areas
. External rain water disposal
. Draught lobbies on external doors |
. Flat roof . Large glazed areas
. Large number of windows
. Many open doors & windows
. Internal pipe-runs & gutters |
|
Building Design (internal) |
. Easy physical access . Fire divisions
. Planned environmental zoning
. Separation of collection (storage &
display) and non-collection areas
. Separation of public access & other areas |
. Poor access
. Lack of internal physical & environmental
barriers
. Mixed use of spaces, causing/requiring
compromises |
|
Building Environment |
. Stable and moderate RH & temperature,
suggesting
- good buffering effect by shell of building from
prevailing weather conditions, and/or
- environmental services control systems that work |
. Fluctuating or extreme RH & temperature,
suggesting
- poor buffering effect of building fabric, and/or
- environmental services control systems that do
not work in desired way |
|
Building Maintenance |
. Sound condition
. Preventive as well as repair maintenance
. Hot work procedures . Disaster plan in place
. Regular checks (& system for fault
logging/rapid repair) of roofs, gutters etc |
. Poor repair . No disaster plan
. No regular checks/reporting procedure
. No procedures governing contractor work |
THE COLLECTION
The
suitability of the building for museum use depends largely
on the nature of the collections that are being kept within
it. Ideally, surveys - either of the collections in their
entirety, or of samples - will be undertaken to uncover and
quantify the current condition of the collection, and
suggest priorities for remedial treatment. At the very
least, a visual inspection should be undertaken, and
regularly repeated. While visual inspection is not ideal as
the only form of check - severe damage may have already
occurred before it is noticed - it is a start. Over time, it
must include inspection of all items, not just those
on display. To facilitate this, it is best that most boxed
items in store are not wrapped, merely padded to prevent
their movement.
TABLE 3: The Basic Types of Museum
Material
|
Organic |
Animal -
Leather, ivory, horn, bone, vellum, feathers, silk,
wool, insect/animal specimens, some paint pigments
Vegetable - Paper, parchment, cotton, wood,
cork, canvas, botanical specimens, some paint pigments |
|
Inorganic |
Man-made -
plastic, metal (iron), metal (non-ferrous), enamel,
ceramic, tile, glass
Natural - stone, geology |
|
Composite (organic) |
Examples: Oil painting on canvas; painted
carved-wood ethnographic mask |
|
Composite (inorganic) |
Examples: Metal & enamel badge; Bakelite radio,
with metal components |
|
Composite (mixed organic/inorganic) |
Examples: Fork with bone handle; Iron tool with
wooden handle; Leather sword scabbard with metal
decoration |
Different
types of collections need different forms of care. However,
it usually impractical to create ideal conditions for each
type. Compromise prevails in most situations, with only the
most `difficult' material subject to specific provision.
Some items, made of composite materials with widely
differing requirements (eg wood & iron) pose particular
problems, that may never be wholly resolved.
All
museum workers need to be aware of the special requirements
of museum collections. Light, temperature and humidity
levels, pests, pollutants and the use of inappropriate
materials, or inadequate handling, all pose threats.
IN-HOUSE PROCEDURES
Comprehensive
and effective in-house procedures are relatively easy to
check. They should be written, and followed. They should
feature in the induction scheme for new staff.
|
Staff
training
. ensure all staff understand the principles and
practice of preventive conservation, ideally as part
of an induction process |
|
Buildings cleaning, inspection & reporting
regimes
. ensure that comprehensive maintenance
checklists are prepared and adhered to |
|
Object movement and handling practices
. avoid object handling wherever possible (eg
within storage boxes padding rather than wrapping
improves access and reduces need to handle)
. when unavoidable, use trained staff, the
correct equipment, and fore-thought
. never move an object until a route has been
cleared, & a space has been made for it to go to
. use cotton gloves for most objects
. permit no smoking, eating or drinking in the
vicinity of collections |
|
Object recording & storage practices
. wherever possible, prevent stored items
touching others
. box or cover items wherever possible, to
protect from dust and light
. raise stored items/storage containers off the
floor in storage areas, in case of flooding
. keep storage areas clean, tidy and uncluttered
. use acid-free boxes where possible, and always
acid-free materials in immediate contact with item,
whether wrapping or padding
. use `object removed cards', when objects have
been temporarily removed from normal location in
stores or display
. ensure that loans out are adequately recorded,
monitored & safeguarded
. record conservation condition and treatments in
the museum documentation system (preferably in an
object history file, filed under accession number) |
|
Emergency Plans
. ensure that damage or breakdown that threatens
the safety of objects (eg to roof, or environmental
control equipment) is repaired immediately; undertake
temporary relocation of objects, or other preventive
action, when rapid repair is not effected
. prepare a comprehensive disaster plan for the
museum |
Disaster
planning for most museums can be achieved by preparation of
an Emergency Manual (such as that developed by EmmS)
containing contact numbers for the various assistance that
can be summoned, and also annotated floor-plans (indicating
features that may be vital in case of fire-fighting or
salvage), and maintenance checklists.
RESPONSES TO A CONSERVATION AUDIT
Deficiencies
highlighted by a conservation audit should be tackled in a
logical and methodical manner. If the audit is not be wasted
effort, adequate resources, both financial and human, should
be provided. Many detailed responses and remedies have
already been described in Table 1. The following are
probably typical responses:
|
. Environmental
zoning, moving collections to the spaces in the
museum with the best inherent environmental
characteristics, thereby minimising the need for
additional measures
. Building works, to improve performance
of the museum `skin' (or, if more cost-effective,
relocation)
. Installation of environmental control
equipment and/or creation of micro-environments
in museum display cases and within stores
. Introduction or extension of appropriate housekeeping
routines and procedures, including a disaster plan
. A programme of remedial conservation,
confident that priorities have been established and
that an appropriate environment is ready to receive
the treated items. |
The following self-assessment form will
help in undertaking a speedy preventive conservation survey,
and help grade your current museum stores?
TABLE 5 - Museum Stores Assessment Guide
|
|
COLLECTIONS WELL MANAGED |
ACCEPTABLE STANDARD |
COLLECTIONS AT RISK |
| |
A |
B |
C |
D |
E |
|
Environment |
. Monitoring
. Air-conditioned
. Stable |
. Monitoring
. Controllable heating
. Humidifiers/de- humidifiers
. Stable |
. Monitoring
. Relatively stable within acceptable limits |
. No monitoring
. No visible deterioration of objects |
. Fluctuation problems eg leaks, damp |
|
Light |
. No daylight
. Monitoring
. Control of individual lighting (eg dimmers,
selective lights)
. Filters |
. Some daylight
. Monitoring
. Control by other means (eg blinds, curtains)
. Filters |
. Daylight
. No monitoring
. Control by other means (eg blinds, curtains)
. Filters |
. Daylight
. No monitoring
. No control
. No filters |
. Substantial daylight
. No monitoring
. No control
. No filters
. Sensitive items at risk |
|
Cleanliness |
. Regular cleaning
. Dust prevention
. Programmed checking of items |
. Regular cleaning
. Dust prevention (eg dust sheet, filter) |
. Regular cleaning
. Anti-dust measures (eg floor covering) |
. Dusty
. Poor dust resistance
. Inadequate floor covering |
. Filthy
. Neglected |
|
General Storage |
. Racks
. Boxes labelled by subject & item
. Handlists
. Access good
. Handling area |
. Racks
. Boxes labelled by subject & item
. Small overspill to floor
. Access good |
. Racks
. Boxes labelled by subject
. Large overspill to floor
. Reasonable access |
. Partially racked
. Boxes
. Access poor
. Damage to objects may occur |
. No racks
. No boxes
. Access very difficult
. Objects at risk |
|
Individual Storage
(assumes a collection for which boxed storage is
appropriate)
|
. Acid-free boxes
. Acid-free packing
. Plenty of room
. Items individually wrapped/packed, compartment-
alised & labelled |
. Acid-free or suitable boxes & packing
. Plenty of room
. Items individually wrapped/
padded/packed to prevent damage |
. Acid-free or suitable boxes
. Adequate wrapping/
padding/ packing |
. Acidic boxes
. No packing, or inadequate/ inappropriate
packing
. Movement will lead to damage |
. Acidic boxes
. No packing
. Cramming or over-
crowding, or free movement, risks/has led to damage |
From the `Collection Care Guide' in Collecting
for the 21st Century (Yorkshire & Humberside Museums
Council 1992)
APPENDIX 1
- Temperature & Humidity
Temperature
and humidity are key agents of deterioration. Relative
humidity (RH) is a ratio of water vapour in the air to the
amount it could hold if fully saturated, and is expressed as
a percentage. Low levels of relative humidity mean dry
conditions since the air is then capable of taking up
moisture. High values are recorded when the air is already
humid or wet and unable to take up much additional moisture.
Temperature with a thermometer; RH is measured with a
hygrometer; a thermohygrometer measures both.
Extreme,
or rapidly fluctuating, relative humidity poses a major
threat, especially to organic materials. Their hygroscopic
nature (they can rapidly absorb and release water) means
that they quickly expand and contract, generating stresses
that threaten release through damage such as cracking. The
goal for most types of museum collection is avoiding rapid
RH change (no greater than +/- 3% in one hour, +/- 5% in 24
hours) while staying within the range of 40-65% RH.
If
relative humidity is controlled, temperature control is
generally less crucial. Ironically, however, since the human
body is far more sensitive to heat and cold than to
humidity, it is temperature control that is more often seen
as the priority in public buildings. Public areas are
usually kept between 17-19oC (63-66oF).
For collections care, a range of 15-25oC is
acceptable for most collections, while stores can be kept at
lower temperatures (there is no lower limit, provided
humidity is still controlled) to both save energy and reduce
decay rates.
TABLE 6 - Evidence of deterioration due
to Temperature and/or Relative Humidity problems
|
MATERIAL |
INDICATOR |
POSSIBLE CAUSE |
|
Metals |
Fresh corrosion products
Tarnish on polished surface |
RH too high (polished metals, e.g. brasses &
bronzes, do not tarnish at 15%RH or less) |
|
Glass
(unstable)
|
`Weeping' - wet surface
`Crizzling' - fine cracks
Glass becoming opaque |
RH incorrect or fluctuating too much |
|
Glass
(stable)
Ceramics
Tile
Unfired Clay
Stone |
Flaking glazes
Powdering fabric
Efflorescence - salts coming out |
RH too high and/or fluctuating too much |
| |
Cracking/Shattering (outdoor location) |
Temperature too low (effect of freeze-thaw action) |
|
Fossils
Minerals |
Pyrite Decay (Sulphide oxidation)
Salt Efflorescence |
RH too high (accelerates deterioration) |
| |
Cracking - sub-fossil bone & shale matrix
around specimens |
RH too low |
|
Natural History |
Mould & Fungus
Distortion of specimens |
RH too high |
| |
`Spring' in insects |
RH fluctuating too much |
|
Wood
Textiles
Bone
Ivory
Leather
Paper |
Mould & Fungus |
RH too high |
| |
Cracks, warping, flaking |
RH fluctuating too much |
| |
Embrittlement
Shrinkage
Drying out & breakdown of adhesives |
RH too low
|
|
Plastic |
Warping |
RH incorrect or fluctuating too much |
| |
Electrostatic/excess dust |
RH too low |
TABLE 7 - Types of Museum Object
requiring exceptional RH conditions
|
MATERIAL |
OPTIMUM RH
(50% unless stated) |
ACCEPTABLE RH BAND
(40%-65% unless stated) |
SENSITIVITY
(_ indicates need for tighter control of RH than +/-3%
per hour, +/-5% per 24 hours) |
NOTES |
|
Excavated Metals
(non-ferrous) |
35% (less if possible) |
15-55% |
|
|
|
Excavated Metals
(ferrous) |
15% (less if possible) |
0-40% |
|
|
|
Coins & Medals |
15% |
15-40% |
|
Depends on corrosion products, oxides and patina
formation, and their degree of stability |
|
Ceramics, Tiles, Stone |
20% |
20-60% |
|
Depends on the activity of embedded salts, and if
corrosion products are present |
|
Geology
(general) |
|
45-55% |
|
|
|
Geology - Pyrites & Marcasite
(& fossils containing these minerals) |
30% |
30-50% |
_ |
Should never exceed 50%RH |
|
Geology - Sub-fossil bone, tusks & teeth;
fossils with shale or clay matrix |
|
|
_ |
Should never be less than 40%RH |
|
Paper |
45% |
40-55% |
|
Some authorities recommend less |
|
Photographs
- B & W prints
- B & W negatives
- glass negatives
- colour prints
- colour slides / colour negatives |
40%
35%
30%
40%
25% |
30-50%
30-40%
20-50%
30-50%
25-30% |
|
|
|
Costumes, Textiles |
|
30-50% |
|
Silk & wool are more sensitive to moisture
damage than cotton or linen. |
|
Glass (crizzled) |
|
|
_ |
Grizzled glass needs a narrow band of controlled RH
to prevent advance of this condition. |
|
Furniture
(inlaid) |
|
|
_ |
Inlay work needs particular stability; exact
sensitivity varies with wood type, adhesive used,
& the condition of surface or barrier coating |
|
Lacquer ware |
|
50-60% |
|
Japanese authorities recommend higher levels (to
70%) |
|
Paper
(stretched) |
|
45-55% |
_ |
Paper screens, drawings on stretched frames etc.
need narrow band |
|
Ivory, bone
(carved) |
|
50-60% |
|
Carved items require more control than anatomical
collections (although less than sub-fossil material).
Dimensional responses very slow, except when in thin
sheets eg miniatures on ivory |
|
Leather, skins, binding |
|
45-60% |
|
Variable according to the tanning process used |
|
Paintings
(on canvas) |
|
40-55% |
_
(see notes) |
Unlined paintings, or paintings lined with
hygroscopic adhesives, are more reactive than those
lined with wax or synthetic materials. NB Some
sources suggest that temperature variations
(even short-term and slight) pose a greater risk than
RH fluctuations, due to varied thermal expansion of
the paint layers |
|
Paintings
(on wood) |
|
45-60% |
_ |
Depends on type, grain & thickness of wood, the
ground and the method of jointing sections. Some need
narrow RH levels to minimise warping |
|
Wood
(painted & varnished) |
|
45-60% |
|
Includes musical instruments, models |
|
Plastic |
40% |
30-50% |
|
In general, plastic materials have slight humidity
responses, but do warp when in thin sheets &
exposed to varying conditions. Low RH causes
electrostatic properties, encouraging dust
accumulation |
|
Parchment, Vellum |
|
50-60% |
_ |
Narrow control required because of great
hygroscopicity |
|
Metalwork
(historic)
|
35% |
15-55% |
|
Depends on condition of metal, and oxide formation.
Other components (eg wooden handles) may restrict
ability to go lower than 50% RH |
APPENDIX 2 - Light
Light
can create serious irreversible damage to museum
collections. Light is a form of energy and can cause fading
as well as deterioration in the materials from which an
object is made. Most objects are to a greater or lesser
extent affected by light, although metals and ceramics not
to the same extent as other materials. Light is measured in
lux (or lumen per square metre. 10 lux equals the amount of
light produced by 1 candle at a distance of one foot
(therefore 10 lux = 1 foot candle).
Light
produces damage in proportion to its intensity and the
exposure time of the object. Thus a light of 500 lux will
theoretically cause the same amount of damage in one year as
a light one-tenth the strength (50 lux) will produce over
ten years; or, if two 100 watt lamps are put in place of
one, then the same amount of damage will occur in half the
time. Thus short exposure to a high lux (eg 2500 lux caused
by photographic or laboratory lights, or 200 lux for short
exhibitions) need not cause undue damage over the total life
of an object, provided this high exposure is compensated by
a proportionate period of time in a lower than normal
illuminance, or in total darkness.
Thus
while it is usual to reduce light-levels in museum displays,
this need not be the only response - reducing the time
during which an item is exposed to light is equally
legitimate. Fitting display lights with a timer, or, if
continuous lighting while on display is required, limiting
the overall time an object is on exhibition in a given year,
is appropriate. For the most light-sensitive objects, it may
be useful to establish annual lux-hours exposure limits. Lux-hours
are a measure of exposure (illuminance x time).
Calculating current exposure in Annual
Lux-hours
|
Lux of display
light source(s) = 50 lux
Number of hours on display in a year = 1,920 (8
hour day x 5 day week x 48 week year)
Annual lux hours exposure = 96,000 lux hours per
year |
This
example assumes that:
.
no light falls on the object when its 8 hour display day is
over (probably only a reality when a regime of covering a
display case);
.
that the lux of the light sources is constant.
In
reality:
.
if any natural light is involved, its illuminance will vary
with the time of day, weather and season;
.
the precise illuminance of many artificial light sources
declines over time, as the filament ages (and dust
settles!);
.
most museum exhibits are illuminated well before (and often
after) public admission times, as lights are turned on,
blinds raised and curtains drawn back, to facilitate gallery
cleaning, out-of-hours events etc.
TABLE 8 - Recommended Light Exposures For
Museum Collections on Display
|
MATERIAL |
RECOMMENDED MAXIMUM VISIBLE LIGHT LEVEL (lumen per
m2, or lux) |
RECOMMENDED MAXIMUM ANNUAL LUX HOURS EXPOSURE
(illuminance x time) B |
|
Costume , textiles
Watercolours, prints, drawings
Paper items (including wallpapers, manuscripts)
Photographic prints (colour)
Transparencies |
50 luxA |
96,000 |
|
Natural history
(most)
Ethnography (most) |
50 luxA |
96,000 |
|
Minerals
(light-sensitive examples, including argentine,
celestite, chalcocite, fluorite, lepidolite,
pyrostilpnite) |
50 - 200 lux |
96,000 - 384,000 |
|
Furniture
(inlaid or with grain/surface feature)
Plastic (especially Bakelite, Ebonite
& polythene) |
100 - 200 lux |
192,000 - 384,000 |
|
Paintings
(oil & tempera)
Undyed leather, wood, horn, bone, ivory
Lacquer ware
Furniture
Photographic Prints (black & white) |
200 lux |
384,000 |
|
Metals
Stone
Glass
Ceramics
Geology
(except some minerals, as above) |
300 lux (material would not be unduly harmed by
higher, but a maximum level at this reduces the eye
adaption difficulties for visitors where other
collections [as above] are displayed in darker
illumination; for similar reasons a maximum
illuminance of 400 lux in the remaining public spaces
in a museum might be recommended) |
576,000+ |
|
A 50 lux
is most often cited in the literature as the
acceptable light level for this category, although
Japanese authorities have chosen 100 lux as the lower
threshold. Museum designers and curators generally
prefer this higher value for reasons of colour
rendition and visitor perception. At all low levels of
illumination the use of an artificial source such as
tungsten light is preferable, as it has a warmer feel
than daylight of the same intensity.
B There is no published source for these
recommendations; they are calculated assuming an
exposure to the recommended maximum lux for 8 hours a
day, five days a week, 48 weeks a year; in many
situations museums will be doing well if they restrict
exposure to no more than double these amounts. |
The
effect of any measures to reduce visible light levels is to
darken a room, a change all the more apparent to the human
eye if made too rapidly. Measures such as the gradual
reduction of lighting levels in preceding spaces, giving
visitors' eyes time to adjust, can usually compensate.
Neutral-density window film reduces the amount of light
entering, but still allows the visitor to look out, while
from the outside the window appears darkened. Widely used on
coaches and railway carriages, such films can offer an
effective alternative to blocking or blinding a window.
Most
light sources also emit some ultraviolet (UV) radiation.
This is light beyond the limit of human vision, at the
violet end of the spectrum, and is also damaging to most
museum objects. Since UV is not needed to view objects, and
can readily be reduced through the use of filters, removal
of the UV element, whether from natural or artificial light
sources, should be the target. A meter is used to measure
the proportion of UV in the light source in microwatts per
lumen (m W/lumen) - a maximum acceptable reading is 75m
W/lumen, although filters should be able to reduce this to
less than 10m W/lumen. A periodic check is needed to test
the continuing efficiency of UV filters (especially of
window coatings and film), as this declines over time.
TABLE 9 - Reducing damage by light - a
summary
|
Reducing the
amount of time an object is illuminated:
. reduce display exposure time (screens or covers
to display cases; timer switches to room/case lights
. reduce overall exposure time (curtain room when
closed; rotate exhibits; set an annual lux-hours
limit; store in darkness) |
|
Reducing the intensity (lux) of the illumination:
. move displays further from light source (ie.
window)
. reduce number of light sources (eg block
windows, less lights)
. reduce intensity of light source (eg partially
blind windows, use neutral density film, reduce
wattage of bulbs and/or use dimmer switches) |
|
Reduce the proportion of ultra-violet (UV) light
striking an object:
. place UV filtering adhesive film or varnish to
external glazing
. replace window, case or picture glass with UV
filtering product - laminated glass (with UV absorbing
interlayer), or special acrylic or polycarbonate
sheets (eg Perspex VE or VA; Plexiglas 201 or 209;
Lexan 9034. NB Ordinary plexiglas or perspex does not
filter UV)
. fit UV filtering diffusers, sleeves or filters
to electric lighting sources
. ensure light illuminating an object is
reflected off a UV absorbing material (eg
white-painted wall) before striking object |
The
radiant heat from lights, especially in enclosed cases,
often poses as much of a problem as the quantity &
quality of the light that they issue. Low-voltage bulbs
often emit great heat. Fluorescent tubes are generally the
coolest, and hence best for mounting inside an enclosed
case. Even so, they need diffusers or sleeves to counter
relatively-high UV emissions.
APPENDIX 3 - Pests
All
museum spaces should be regularly set with traps to detect
the presence of pests, hopefully before their numbers are a
problem. Simple `window' traps placed along skirting boards
(the usual insect run) can be very effective, and are cheap
and long-lasting. They are most likely to detect pests in
May - July, the months when most adult forms migrate to
breed. By carefully noting which traps have caught what
insects, the source of the problem can be identified. It
will frequently be a hole in the building fabric, permitting
ingress; alternatively, an item already infested with eggs
or larvae may have been introduced to the store or display.
Measures to prevent pest infestation, and
to mitigate their effects:
|
. Set
monitoring traps widely; inspect regularly
. Ensure gaps in building fabric are closed
(close pest entry routes)
. Keep temperatures low (most practical in
stores)
. Inspect collections regularly, especially the
most `at risk' items (which might be labelled as such)
. Isolate or cover new acquisitions, to contain
any emerging adults, if in doubt about their state
. Remove external accretions of pigeon droppings
(carpet beetle larvae love this); try to deny roosts
on ledges
. Have good housekeeping regimes, that remove
dust (curved skirting boards reduce it collecting)
and, in particular, clean light fittings (warm places,
where insect corpses can gather, especially in
fluorescent light diffusers) |
APPENDIX 4
- Pollutants
Pollutants
in the museum atmosphere require identification and
measurement, and, if they pose a threat to the collection,
exclusion. Sources of pollutants are both internal and
external.
External
sources for both gas and particle pollution include vehicle
and factory emissions, and burning fossil fuels. Within the
museum they may derive from building works, items already in
the collection (eg cellulose nitrate film, or collections in
formaldehyde), cleaning agents, or materials used to
construct display cases, or provide storage.
Of
particular concern (but relatively easy to correct) are
materials used to construct museum displays. In the confined
atmosphere of a display case, levels of harmful pollutants
can cause chemical changes, even without physical contact.
For example, hydrogen sulphide, exuded by wool,
leather, parchment and certain adhesives, will tarnish
silver, polished copper and photographic prints &
negatives; sulphur dioxide will harm paper, leather
and some types of stone, while organic acids (eg acetic
acid), contained naturally in wood, are catalysts for
much corrosion, particularly of lead.
TABLE 10 - Materials for Display &
Storage
|
MATERIAL |
PROBLEMS |
GENERAL RULES |
BEST |
WORST |
|
Wood |
. Acids are released that may damage objects |
. No wood is perfect
. Consider substitutes (eg acrylic sheet,
glass)
. If must use, cover wood on side facing inside a
case with an impermeable material1 to
improve the seal around the wood
. Wherever possible seal wood with suitable
- paint
- varnish
- lacquer
|
. Aged
. Seasoned
. Dry
. Certain species
(eg beech; birch, mahogany) |
. Green
. Unseasoned
. Knots
. Certain species
(eg red cedar, oak, Douglas fir, sweet chestnut) |
|
Wood Panel Products |
. Emission of organic acids from the wood
. Emission of vapours from formaldehyde- based
resins used as the bonding adhesive
. There is little control over the wood species
used |
. No wood product panel is perfect
. Consider substitutes (eg acrylic sheet,
glass)
. If must use, cover wood product panels on side
facing inside a case with an impermeable material1
to improve the seal around the panel
. Wherever possible seal wood product panels (especially
cut edges) with suitable
- paint
- varnish
- lacquer |
. Products intended for marine or exterior use
. Overlaid plywood (eg high density overlaid [HDO]
plywood; medium density overlaid [MDO] plywood)
. Plastic-laminated panels (eg melamine,
formica)
. Blockboard |
. Chipboard
. Hardboard
. Plywood (interior grade) |
|
Plastics & Rubber |
. Some plastics release harmful degradation
products and additives
. Rubber is not stable & perishes under most
conditions over time |
. Choose acid-free (or acid- reduced) products
. Avoid Polyurethane or rubber-based materials |
. Polyethylene (PE)
. Polypropylene (PP)
. Polyester
|
. Poly vinyl chloride (PVC)
. Rubber with sulphur vulcanising agents |
|
Foams & Foam Boards |
|
|
. Polyethylene (PE) foam (eg plastazote)
|
. Polystyrene
. Polyurethane foam board
. PVC foam board |
|
Paints, Varnishes & Stains |
. Release organic acid vapours, peroxides etc at
different rates
. Efficiency as a barrier to volatiles is
variable from product to product
. No coating is a complete barrier |
. Wait at least one month before putting object
in a closed system, to allow for evaporation of
solvents
. Cover coating on side facing inside a case with
an impermeable material1 to improve the
seal around the coating
|
. Water-based paints
|
. Corrosion-resistant paints
. Oil-based paints
. Oil-modified polyurethane varnish |
|
Adhesives |
. Release corrosive or otherwise damaging gases
during curing or on ageing
. Solvents & adhesives may be transferred to
objects
. Adhesives may embrittle, ooze, yellow, become
acidic |
. Use alternatives if possible (eg screws for
joints, brass staples for attaching lining fabrics)
. Wait at least one month before putting object
in a closed system, to allow for evaporation of
| |